We thought it couldn’t get any better when Joe Jonas dressed up as Sansa Stark last weekend, but the pop star just proved us wrong with his latest Halloween costume. Taking a couples’ costume approach, Jonas and his fiancée, Game of Thrones actress Sophie Turner, transformed into Morticia and Gomez Addams on Halloween night. Their costumes were so spot on, Jonas and Turner were hardly even recognizable.

Jonas and Turner both posted the costumes on their Instagram accounts just as the spooky holiday came to a close. Jonas dressed in Gomez’s classic pinstripe suit and black tie with slicked-back hair and a dark black moustache. With skin extra pale for effect, Turner dressed in a sultry black waist-hugging gown with a high leg slit and low-cut neckline. She also wore a long black wig and Morticia’s bright red lipstick. Props played a big role in the costumes, too—Jonas held a cigar in one hand, while Turner posed with scissors ready to snip a bouquet of roses. To top things off, Jonas was even accompanied by a prosthetic hand (to represent the character Thing) sitting on his shoulder!

Because Jonas and Turner are so extra, they had to show off their looks in an Addams family photoshoot. In one image, the couple stood in front of a brown wood wall and gave the most unimpressed glares to the camera. The second photo on Jonas’s Instagram showed him in sitting at a piano, playing a few notes and staring menacingly.

View this post on Instagram

Happy Halloween from Morticia & Gomez Addams

A post shared by J O E J O N A S (@joejonas) on

Turner shared an additional photo, taken by makeup artist Dusty Starks, in which Turner leaned against Jonas while he sat and looked past the camera. Turner’s amazing smokey-eye look was on full display.

Finally, the couple shared a black-and-white video of the two walking towards the camera, set to the Addams Family theme song. Jonas smoked his cigar while Turner snipped away at her roses, and of course there were no smiles.

Jonas had already stolen the Halloween show last weekend when he paid homage to his fiancée’s Game of Thrones character, Sansa Stark. The DNCE singer attended Kate Hudson’s annual Halloween party in L.A. wearing a teal gown and a red wig. On Instagram, he shared a video of himself posing in the outfit while the GoT theme song played. Even though Turner attended the party dressed as a giant cuddly elephant, they still made the cutest couple.

Which Jonas costume did you like better—Sansa Stark or Gomez Addams? Let us know in the comments!

READ NEXT: Beyoncé's Toni Braxton Halloween Costume Is So On Point It's Scary

About The Author